Isaiah 12:1
1In that day you will say, “I will give thanks to you, the LORD; for though you were angry with me, your anger has turned away and you comfort me.
In that day you will say, I will give thanks to you, the LORD; for though you were angry with me, your anger has turned away and you comfort me. Wesley: in that day—when the reduction of Israel and conversion of the Gentiles is fulfilled (11:10–16).
Remnant first, then the nations. A thanks after an anger. They still say it. The stretched-out hand of 9–10 has turned.
Calvin: the song seals the promise, put in their mouth so they will not think they are deluded. He addresses the whole people as one. Believers first acknowledge guilt, then ascribe relief to mercy. He was satisfied with moderate chastisement. Anger of short duration (Ps 30:5). Punishment ended not because we paid what we deserved, but because through fatherly love He spares our weakness. This confession belongs properly to the godly and elect. Wrath against the ungodly is perpetual; their chastisements are forerunners of everlasting destruction; no consolation is promised them. The godly are trained to repentance, that they may not perish with the world (1 Cor 11:32).
“That day”—the elect’s song after the rod. That day, thanks, angry with me, anger turned away, comfort.
Key contrast Both confess that in that day they thank the Lord whose anger turned away to comfort (12:1). Arminians hear the day when Israel is reduced and the Gentiles converted, a people who may then praise (Wesley). Reformed interpreters hear a confession that belongs to the godly and elect: wrath short for them, perpetual for the ungodly; they were not billed and paid, but spared by fatherly love (Calvin).