Passage

Matthew 17

Verses 24–27 WEB Voices

In Capernaum collectors ask Peter whether Jesus pays the two-drachma temple tax. Jesus teaches Peter that sons are free, yet provides a miraculous shekel from a fish’s mouth so as not to give offense—paying for Himself and for Peter.

Matthew 17:24

24When they had come to Capernaum, those who collected the didrachma coins came to Peter, and said, “Doesn’t your teacher pay the didrachma?”

Arminian

The question probes loyalty and practice. Collectors approach Peter, assuming the Teacher’s household pattern.

Public witness includes ordinary obligations. How disciples answer shapes whether the gospel is needlessly obstructed.

Reformed

Temple tax collectors test the Capernaum base. The query is loaded: is Jesus inside Israel’s pious norms?

Christ will answer on His terms. Identity as Son will interpret the tax before money appears.

Matthew 17:25

25He said, “Yes.” When he came into the house, Jesus anticipated him, saying, “What do you think, Simon? From whom do the kings of the earth receive toll or tribute? From their children, or from strangers?”

Arminian

Peter answers yes; Jesus then catechizes him first—omniscience meeting the conversation Peter just had. The king-and-sons analogy prepares freedom.

Jesus forms conscience by questions. Grace teaches freedom without training disciples in careless offense.

Reformed

Jesus initiates before Peter reports. Royal logic: kings tax others, not their own sons.

The Son knows and leads. Theology of sonship precedes the coin; status in the kingdom interprets civic-religious dues.

Matthew 17:26

26Peter said to him, “From strangers.” Jesus said to him, “Therefore the children are exempt.

Arminian

Peter supplies the obvious answer; Jesus draws the line: sons are free. Temple dues do not bind the Son as a mere subject.

Arminians hear liberty in Christ without antinomian swagger. Freedom is true—and love will still choose careful paths for others’ sake.

Reformed

“The children are exempt. But, lest we cause them” is christological before it is ethical. Jesus claims household freedom under the Father’s kingship.

The Son is not a debtor to the temple as outsiders are. Freedom is His by identity; any payment will be voluntary wisdom.

Key contrast Both affirm the Son’s freedom. Arminians typically move quickly to liberty exercised in love so as not to hinder others; Reformed readers typically root the freedom first in Christ’s unique sonship, then in wise condescension.

Matthew 17:27

27But, lest we cause them to stumble, go to the sea, cast a hook, and take up the first fish that comes up. When you have opened its mouth, you will find a stater coin. Take that, and give it to them for me and you.”

Arminian

Freedom yields to love: pay anyway, lest needless offense block the message. The fish-and-shekel sign supplies what Peter lacks and covers both Teacher and disciple.

Christian liberty is not a club. Grace frees us in Christ and frees us to serve—paying costs that protect witness and neighbor.

Reformed

Not to give offense governs the miracle. Providence puts a shekel in a fish’s mouth; Peter hooks provision for two.

The free Son chooses temporary accommodation, and the Father funds it. Christ’s kingdom advances without pointless scandal over a tax He did not owe.

Historic quotes

Voices from both camps

Classic Arminian and Reformed comment on Matthew 17:24–27, in the writers’ own words.

Arminian Notable voices

“When they were come to Capernaum - Where our Lord now dwelt. This was the reason why they stayed till he came thither, to ask him for the tribute. - This was a tribute or payment of a peculiar kind, being half a shekel, (that is, about fifteen pence,) which every master of a family used to pay yearly to the service of the temple, to buy salt, and little things not otherwise provided for.”

John Wesley · Explanatory Notes upon the New Testament (on Matt 17:24–27)

Reformed Notable voices

“We must attend, first of all, to the design of this narrative; which is, that Christ, by paying tribute of his own accord, declared his subjection, as he had taken upon him the form of a servant, (Philippians 2:7,) but at the same time showed, both by words and by the miracle, that it was not by obligation or necessity, but by a free and voluntary submission, that he had reduced himself so low that the world looked upon him as nothing more than one of the common people.”

John Calvin · Commentary on a Harmony of the Evangelists (on Matt 17:24–27)

Quotations lightly abridged for length; wording follows standard English translations of the sources named.

Keep reading

Genesis, Psalms, Isaiah, Daniel, Matthew, John, Romans, Ephesians, Colossians, 1 Timothy, 2 Timothy, Titus, Hebrews, 1 John, 2 John, and 3 John are live

Browse verse-by-verse notes—Arminian and Reformed, side by side—kept fair and close to the text.

Browse the Bible