Psalms 119:17
17Do good to your servant. I will live and I will obey your word.
Wesley: Live—safely and comfortably.
Classical Arminians hear bounty asked so that life and obedience may flourish together. Keeping the word is the aim of living, not a side hobby. Grace is petitioned; the servant does not claim self-made fidelity.
Calvin: gamal here expresses free favor, not mutual recompense. Preferable sense: grant that while I live I may keep thy commandments. The grand object of existence is exercising oneself in God’s service. It is owing to the peculiar grace of the Spirit that any keeps the law; if preparation depended on free will, the prayer would be hypocrisy.
Live-and-keep is one gift of free favor. Prolongation of life without this aim is irrational appetite.
Key contrast Both tie life to keeping God’s word and both ask bounty rather than claim native power. Arminians typically hear free grace sincerely enabling the servant who asks to live and keep. Calvinists hear Calvin’s sharper edge: keeping is peculiar grace of the Spirit, and any notion that we prepare ourselves by free will for that keeping would make the prayer hypocrisy.