Psalms 22:1
1My God, my God, why have you forsaken me? Why are you so far from helping me, and from the words of my groaning?
Wesley: My God—who art my friend and father, though now thou frownest upon me. The repetition denotes the depth of his distress. Forsaken—withdrawn the light of thy countenance, the supports and comforts of thy spirit, and filled me with the terrors of thy wrath: this was in part verified in David, but much more fully in Christ. Roaring—out-cries forced by miseries.
Shared messianic confession: Matthew 27:46 and Mark 15:34 put this cry on Christ’s lips. The forsaking is true—wrath’s terrors, not play-acting—yet “My God” still claims the Father. Grace enables the sufferer to keep crying; the hearer must not let the frown cancel the name.
Calvin: two contrary sentences enter the godly mind together—forsakenness that sounds like despair, and “My God! my God!” that confesses faith. Faith is given the first place before the complaint; the reprobate, cherishing distrust, are overwhelmed and cannot aspire after grace by faith. Christ used these words on the cross as our representative under the curse, yet without sin; the psalm is prophecy concerning David’s King and Lord.
Christ truly cried this. The conflict trains the elect: flesh feels cast off; faith beholds hidden grace in the promises until the Father’s countenance returns.
Key contrast Both confess the shared christology of the forsaken cry—Christ on the cross spoke these words under judicial sorrow, not mere theatre. Following Wesley, Arminian readers stress the depth of withdrawn comfort and wrath’s terrors, and the grace-enabled duty still to claim “My God” while the frown lasts. Reformed interpreters stress that faith precedes and corrects the complaint, and that the elect wrestle without being swallowed as the reprobate are when distrust takes entire possession.